[Day 26] BMAD-Method v6 - part 1

在幾個禮拜前，BMAD-Method v6 alpha已經推出了，寫到這時候剛好看他推出新內容，又有題材可以加進來！這幾天來大概跑一下V6 alpha有哪些更新，同時我Day 18 記帳app開發也即將進入尾聲，過幾天也可以整理上來了。

Scale Adaptive Framework

https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD/blob/main/src/modules/bmm/docs/scale-adaptive-system.md

這次把story數量劃分為5個等級，每個等級產出不同量級的文件，並大致規劃了完成時間

Level	Scope	Stories	Documentation	Keywords	Timeline
0	Single atomic change	1	tech-spec only	fix, bug, typo, small change, patch	Hours
1	Small feature	1-10	tech-spec + epic	simple, basic, small feature, add, minor	Days
2	Medium project	5-15	PRD + optional arch	dashboard, several features, admin panel, medium	Weeks
3	Complex integration	12-40	PRD + architecture	platform, integration, complex, system, architecture	Months
4	Enterprise scale	40+	Full methodology	enterprise, multi-tenant, multiple products, ecosystem, scale	Quarters

當執行 workflow-init 的時候會用三個方式評估專案大小

Keyword Analysis: 描述中是否有Level特定的關鍵字
Story Count Estimation: 根據story數量評估，有些level會有overlap則會再根據需求做選擇。
Complexity Indicators: 是否有其他額外的需求要考慮

BMad C.O.R.E.

https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD/tree/750024fb14a86816020caa9fdabd45d2235f1639?tab=readme-ov-file#v6-core-enhancements

是C.O.R.E也是core，BMad Core 與 Method 分離，提供更乾淨的核心引擎(engine)，讓方法論(method)可以用多種模組化插件擴充。

- Collaboration: Human-AI partnership leveraging complementary strengths
- Optimized: Battle-tested processes for maximum effectiveness
- Reflection: Strategic questioning that unlocks breakthrough solutions
- Engine: Framework orchestrating 19+ specialized agents and 50+ workflows

BMad-CORE 這邊最後一句話很有意思

BMad-CORE doesn’t give you answers—it helps you discover better solutions through guided reflection.

自訂語言和自訂 Agent (Custom Language & Custom Agents)

https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD/tree/750024fb14a86816020caa9fdabd45d2235f1639?tab=readme-ov-file#v6-core-enhancements v6-alpha提供了更高彈性、更方便自定義的方法，可以自訂要跟BMad-Method溝通的語言、同時可以自訂自己的Agent

- Agent Customization - Modify names, roles, personalities via bmad/_cfg/agents/
- Multi-Language - Independent language settings for communication and output
- Personalization - Agents adapt to your name, skill level, and preferences
- Persistent Config - Customizations survive module updates
- Flexible Settings - Configure per-module or globally

可以看到從溝通語言、人格、module、到global setting，都可以定義你或你專案想要、需要的內容。

專案類型和參考架構 (Project Types & Reference Architectures)

https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD/tree/750024fb14a86816020caa9fdabd45d2235f1639/src/modules/bmm/workflows/2-plan-workflows/prd 裡面的project-types.csv定義了10種project types，比v4多了更多。同時，參考架構 (Reference Architectures)透過開放社群貢獻，可以讓greenfield更快從0到1、更快開發MVP

project_type	detection_signals	key_questions	required_sections	skip_sections	web_search_triggers	innovation_signals
api_backend	API,REST,GraphQL,backend,service,endpoints	Endpoints needed?; Authentication method?; Data formats?; Rate limits?; Versioning?; SDK needed?	endpoint_specs; auth_model; data_schemas; error_codes; rate_limits; api_docs	ux_ui; visual_design; user_journeys	framework best practices; OpenAPI standards	API composition; New protocol
mobile_app	iOS,Android,app,mobile,iPhone,iPad	Native or cross-platform?; Offline needed?; Push notifications?; Device features?; Store compliance?	platform_reqs; device_permissions; offline_mode; push_strategy; store_compliance	desktop_features; cli_commands	app store guidelines; platform requirements	Gesture innovation; AR/VR features
saas_b2b	SaaS,B2B,platform,dashboard,teams,enterprise	Multi-tenant?; Permission model?; Subscription tiers?; Integrations?; Compliance?	tenant_model; rbac_matrix; subscription_tiers; integration_list; compliance_reqs	cli_interface; mobile_first	compliance requirements; integration guides	Workflow automation; AI agents
developer_tool	SDK,library,package,npm,pip,framework	Language support?; Package managers?; IDE integration?; Documentation?; Examples?	language_matrix; installation_methods; api_surface; code_examples; migration_guide	visual_design; store_compliance	package manager best practices; API design patterns	New paradigm; DSL creation
cli_tool	CLI,command,terminal,bash,script	Interactive or scriptable?; Output formats?; Config method?; Shell completion?	command_structure; output_formats; config_schema; scripting_support	visual_design; ux_principles; touch_interactions	CLI design patterns; shell integration	Natural language CLI; AI commands
web_app	website,webapp,browser,SPA,PWA	SPA or MPA?; Browser support?; SEO needed?; Real-time?; Accessibility?	browser_matrix; responsive_design; performance_targets; seo_strategy; accessibility_level	native_features; cli_commands	web standards; WCAG guidelines	New interaction; WebAssembly use
game	game,player,gameplay,level,character	REDIRECT TO GAME WORKFLOWS	game-brief; GDD	most_sections	game design patterns	Novel mechanics; Genre mixing
desktop_app	desktop,Windows,Mac,Linux,native	Cross-platform?; Auto-update?; System integration?; Offline?	platform_support; system_integration; update_strategy; offline_capabilities	web_seo; mobile_features	desktop guidelines; platform requirements	Desktop AI; System automation
iot_embedded	IoT,embedded,device,sensor,hardware	Hardware specs?; Connectivity?; Power constraints?; Security?; OTA updates?	hardware_reqs; connectivity_protocol; power_profile; security_model; update_mechanism	visual_ui; browser_support	IoT standards; protocol specs	Edge AI; New sensors
blockchain_web3	blockchain,crypto,DeFi,NFT,smart contract	Chain selection?; Wallet integration?; Gas optimization?; Security audit?	chain_specs; wallet_support; smart_contracts; security_audit; gas_optimization	traditional_auth; centralized_db	blockchain standards; security patterns	Novel tokenomics; DAO structure

BMAD Builder

https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD?tab=readme-ov-file#bmad-builder-bmb---create-custom-solutions

這跟Core一樣都是很關鍵的一個功能，幫助使用者建立自己的工作流程、Agent，甚至是完整的自訂模組。

- Custom Agents: Domain experts with specialized knowledge
- Guided Workflows: Multi-step processes for any task
- Complete Modules: Full solutions for specific domains

值得注意的是他又把agent分成了3個type: Full module, hybrid, or standalone，這也更容易達成Agent-as-code、也可以設計出更符合domain領域的agnet.

Perfect For: Creating domain-specific solutions (legal, medical, finance, education, creative, etc.) or extending BMM with custom development workflows.

也因此讓BMAD-Method更加強大。